Most “conversion rate” checklists online are the same twelve items reshuffled: “add social proof,” “make your CTA pop,” “reduce friction.” None of them tell you what to actually look for on your own site. So here is the real list, the one we run on every client project in the week before launch, written so you can run it on your own site today.
This covers seven checks, in the order we run them, with what to do when a check fails.
Why the generic lists don’t help
A list that says “use social proof” is true and useless. The question that actually matters is: proof of what, placed where, next to which decision? We have sat through enough launch reviews to know that the gap is never strategy. It is that nobody went through the site page by page and asked “would I click here, and if not, why not.” That is what this checklist forces.
We ran it last quarter on a SaaS client’s marketing site two days before launch and failed on three of the seven checks: two competing CTAs on the pricing page, a testimonials section that nobody had filled in since the template was handed over, and a contact form asking for company size and budget range before anyone had spoken to a human. All three were copy fixes, not redesign work, and all three shipped before the site went live.
1. One primary call to action per page
Open any page and count the competing actions: book a call, download a guide, follow on LinkedIn, sign up for the newsletter, view pricing. If there are more than one or two, a visitor does the easiest thing, which is usually nothing. Pick the one action that page should drive and demote everything else to a footer link.
2. Real proof, placed near the decision, not buried
Testimonials living on a dedicated “testimonials” page nobody visits do nothing. The fix is to move one specific quote, with a real name and title, next to the CTA where someone is actually deciding whether to reach out: the bottom of a services page, right above the contact form, inside a pricing section. A quote that says “Redmonk redesigned our checkout flow and we stopped losing carts at the payment step” earns more trust sitting next to a button than the same quote parked on page six.
3. Numbers that are actually filled in
We once opened a client’s homepage days before launch and found three stat counters — years in business, clients served, countries served — all rendering blank, because the template shipped with placeholder values nobody replaced. A blank counter reads as a broken website, not an understated one. Even a conservative real number beats an empty box.
4. A headline that names who you help and what breaks without you
“We craft exceptional digital experiences” could be the homepage of three thousand agencies. The fix is a formula, not inspiration: who you help, plus the specific problem you solve, plus the outcome they care about. “Websites that win clients, designed for Indian startups and SMBs who are tired of agencies that disappear after launch” tells a visitor in one line whether to keep reading.
5. Pricing signals, even rough ones
No price range anywhere means every enquiry starts from zero information, which is why so many contact-form conversations end at “what’s your budget.” A simple “projects typically start from ‹X›” line, or a three-tier package overview, filters out mismatched enquiries before they reach your inbox and reassures the right ones that they are in the right place.
6. A contact form with three fields, not nine
Name, email, and a one-line project description is enough to start a conversation. Every additional required field — company size, budget range, how did you hear about us, preferred contact method — is a reason for someone to close the tab instead. Ask the extra questions on the call, not the form.
7. Something measured, even by hand
The last check is the one most sites fail silently: is anything actually being counted? A contact form that submits successfully but fires no event anywhere means nobody can tell a good week from a bad one. We have seen analytics setups report mostly bot traffic from data-centre cities with four-second “engagement” times, which is not a traffic number anyone should act on. If your analytics setup is not there yet, count enquiries by hand from the inbox every week. That number beats a dashboard full of unfiltered, mostly-bot traffic.
This check matters more than it looks. A site can pass every other item on this list and still leave you guessing whether any of it worked, simply because nobody can say which page, which post, or which change actually produced an enquiry.
Run it yourself
- One clear primary action per page, everything else demoted
- A named, specific testimonial next to the decision point, not on a separate page
- Every stat counter, if you have one, showing a real number
- A headline naming who you help and what breaks without you
- A visible price anchor, even a rough one
- A contact form with three fields, not nine
- A weekly enquiry count, counted by hand if the dashboard can’t be trusted yet
None of these need a redesign. Most are an afternoon of edits to copy that already exists on the site.
Working on something similar?
We run this exact list on every client site before we call a project done, and we are happy to run it on yours. Have a look at our design work at redmonk.in/design, or if you want a second pair of eyes on a specific page, Start a project and tell us which one.